According to this 2026 influencer marketing benchmark report from Influencer Marketing Hub, which surveyed 600+ people in the influencer marketing space, 56.5% of all reported fraud and quality issues in the industry stem from fake or bot followers – a real problem for any brand chasing data-driven growth.
Which means that, as a result, influencer spend is often still assessed based on unreal numbers.
Only 10.9% of the survey respondents picked ‘none of the above’ as their concern around fraud/quality risks – which means that close to 90% have experienced at least one type of fraud or quality issue in their programs.
Which is important for anyone that’s looking to connect Instagram spend to business results.
Because if part of a creator’s audience is fake, then all of the downstream metrics – like reach, cost per engagement and so on – will be distorted. Which means that any ROI calculation based on those metrics will also be off the mark from the outset.
What follower counts say about reach
Back in September 2025, Instagram chief Adam Mosseri announced that the app had passed 3 billion monthly active users, crediting DMs, Reels and recommendations as the key growth drivers, with Reels reportedly now making up 50% of time spent in the app.
With Reels taking up more of that time, more of what people see is likely coming from accounts they don’t follow, rather than from profiles they’ve chosen to connect with, which could also be changing what a follower count tells you about reach.
That doesn’t make followers irrelevant. But it does suggest that a big follower count, on its own, is a weaker signal of who’ll actually see a sponsored post – and weaker still if part of that following is bots.
So the more useful questions are who’s really engaging, where they’re based, and whether they match the customers a brand wants to reach.
The measurement gap in influencer budgets
At this stage, 72.2% of the people surveyed by Influencer Marketing Hub expect to increase their influencer budgets by 50% or more this year.
Of those planning to increase their influencer budgets, 89% stated that brand awareness is a key performance indicator (KPI) that they’ll track in their campaigns, while only 25% are tracking attributable revenue or sales.
Which is interesting, because the fastest spend-growers in the industry are also significantly more likely to measure awareness metrics than revenue.
Which is pretty tricky to relate to ROI, of course, because awareness is far more difficult to correlate with return on investment, as opposed to, say, measuring the amount of revenue that a brand actually generates as a result of its influencer campaign.
Which, ideally, you would be able to track, but given that only a quarter of that group is actually tracking revenue figures, it’s not clear to what extent this is actually data-driven growth, as opposed to an industry that’s growing based on reach figures that may include a lot of fake accounts.
And it’s a self-reported survey, with 600+ respondents, which is interesting in that it’s based on what people say they plan to do, or have experienced, but not based on actual measured spend, or fraud rates.
How can brands verify an Instagram audience?
I’d say the best starting point is the data Instagram itself provides, which Meta’s been working to make more accessible to brands.
At IAB NewFronts in May 2025, Meta announced that it was adding interaction rate, creators’ past partners and hook rate – i.e. roughly how well a creator’s videos hold viewers past the opening seconds – as search options in Instagram’s ‘Creator Marketplace’, while also beginning a limited test of a discovery API for the marketplace.
Then in September 2025, Meta said that its ‘Creator Marketplace’ API would enable brands to retrieve account-level information on a creator, ‘including their audience demographics and average engagement rate’.
That’s first-party data from Instagram’s own systems, as opposed to estimates from external tools, which could make it a more trustworthy basis for choosing creators.
Of course, Meta’s announcements don’t detail how suspected bot accounts are handled within these figures. But checking a creator’s audience location and engagement rate against their media kit is a simple step that could weed out some of the worst offenders.
And audience verification matters beyond influencer partnerships, too. Brands looking to build an Instagram presence through an existing audience face many of the same questions.
Buying an established Instagram audience
The same logic applies to brands that want to own an audience outright, with marketplaces like Social Tradia listing established Instagram accounts for sale across a range of niches.
From beauty and luxury to tech and science Instagram pages, these accounts could appeal to brands looking to reach a specific interest group without starting from zero.
But a page is only worth what its followers are. So the same audience location and engagement checks, plus a look at how the following has grown, would need to come before any deal.
Is Instagram influencer marketing worth it?
It can be, though the answer depends far more on audience quality than on audience size.
With close to nine in ten respondents seemingly having run into some form of fraud or quality issue, the brands that’ll likely see the best returns in the app are those that verify who they’re paying to reach before a campaign, then measure what that audience does after it.
That’s not a radical approach, and it does add some work up front. But given how often fake followers come up as a problem, it could be worth treating audience verification as the first step in any ROI calculation, rather than an afterthought once the results come in.